Tilio
Claim your ChatGPT profile

What AI search optimisation can and can’t do

AI search optimisation, often called answer engine optimisation (AEO), can make a business easier for AI assistants to find, quote and describe accurately. It can’t guarantee a recommendation, buy a place in an answer or control what an assistant says. Quick fixes such as an llms.txt file or FAQ schema don’t change who gets recommended on their own.

By Jack F12 min read

Which of these twelve claims are true?

One holds as stated: AI visibility can grow while your traffic stays flat. The other eleven are false, or need evidence before you believe them, and each links to the section with that evidence.

Twelve claims about AI search optimisation, with a verdict and the reason for each
ClaimVerdictWhy
An agency can guarantee you a recommendation in ChatGPTFalseNobody outside OpenAI controls what ChatGPT says, and the brands it names change from answer to answer.
You can pay to appear in ChatGPT’s or Google’s organic answersFalseAds are labelled as sponsored and kept apart, and both companies say ads don’t influence the answer.
An llms.txt file will improve your AI visibilityFalseGoogle Search ignores it, and Ahrefs found 97% of the files weren’t requested once in a month.
FAQ schema makes AI assistants recommend youFalseGoogle says no special schema is needed for its AI features.
Blocking AI training also blocks you from AI searchFalseTraining and search use separate crawlers, and each can be allowed or blocked on its own.
Publishing more content automatically improves AI visibilityFalseVolume alone doesn’t help, and Google treats mass-produced pages as spam.
AEO means rewriting your whole websiteFalseIn our study, 96.5% of citations went to sites the brand didn’t own.
Being recommended by AI is the same as ranking on GoogleFalseOnly 38% of pages cited in AI Overviews also ranked in the top 10.
An agency can control how AI describes your brandFalseIt can change the sources AI reads, not the answer itself.
AI visibility can grow while your traffic stays flatTrueMany people see you in an answer and never click, or arrive later by another route.
More AI visibility always means more leadsFalseBeing named isn’t being chosen, and enquiries need a page that leads somewhere.
A guarantee, an instant result or a single fixQuestion itNone of them survives a look at how AI answers are built.

Can any AEO agency guarantee a recommendation in ChatGPT?

No. Nobody outside OpenAI controls what ChatGPT says, and the same question brings back a different list of brands almost every time. An agency can raise how often you’re named, but it can’t promise a place.

OpenAI says as much about its own tools. Its help centre says claiming your business in ChatGPT doesn’t guarantee more visibility, and that advertising doesn’t influence ChatGPT’s independent answers. If the platform doesn’t promise a place, nobody selling services around it can.

The answers are also too changeable to promise. When SparkToro and Gumshoe collected 2,961 runs of the same 12 questions, the same list of brands came back less than once in 100 runs on ChatGPT and Google’s AI.

Treat guaranteed AI citations and immediate results the same way. A new page can be cited within days: our AI search attribution page entered our sitemap on 13 November 2026, and ChatGPT first cited it the next day. But one citation isn’t a trend, and a lasting rise in how often you’re named is judged over months.

What works instead is slower: clear pages, accurate facts and coverage on the sites AI already reads, measured on the same questions over time.

Can we pay an AI platform to include us in its organic answers?

No. You can buy ads in ChatGPT and around Google’s AI answers, but they’re labelled as sponsored and kept apart from the answer. Both OpenAI and Google say ads don’t influence what the AI says.

Google’s Ads help is unambiguous: “Paid advertising does not influence the organic responses generated by Google AI.” OpenAI’s announcement of ads says the same of its own product: “Ads do not influence the answers ChatGPT gives you.” In ChatGPT, ads show on the Free and Go plans, labelled as sponsored.

OpenAI announced a UK rollout of ads in ChatGPT on 7 May 2026. When we checked Google’s list of countries with ads inside AI Overviews and AI Mode on 19 November 2026, the UK wasn’t on it. Both are moving quickly, so check before you plan a budget, and our post on whether ChatGPT ads are worth it for UK brands covers the trade-offs.

A business can buy its way into AI source lists, but not into the answer. Coverage on sites AI already cites, such as trade publications, review sites and directories, can be earned through PR or placed through a paid partnership, labelled as such. It can help, because AI answers draw on those sites. The engine still chooses its sources and decides what to say, so a placement is a chance to be read, not a guaranteed mention.

Will an llms.txt file alone improve our AI visibility?

No. Google says its Search ignores llms.txt files, and Ahrefs found 97% of them weren’t requested once in a month. It does no harm, and it isn’t a lever.

An llms.txt file is a plain text file at the root of a website that lists its main pages for AI tools. The idea caught on fast: when Ahrefs checked 137,210 sites, 28% had published one. But 97% of those files got no requests at all in May 2026, and Ahrefs called the file “largely decoration” for AI search.

Google is direct about it. Its guide to generative AI features says Google Search ignores llms.txt and other AI-specific files, and that special formatting isn’t required.

If you already have one, there’s no need to take it down. Just don’t count it as AI search work. What works instead is making sure AI crawlers can reach your pages, and that the pages say plainly what you do.

Will adding FAQ schema make AI assistants recommend our business?

No. Google says no special schema is needed to appear in its AI features. Schema helps a machine read the facts on a page, but it doesn’t make an assistant recommend you.

Schema, also called structured data, is code that labels the facts on a page, such as a price, an address or a question and its answer, so software can read them reliably. Google’s page on AI features and your website is plain about it: “There’s also no special schema.org structured data that you need to add.” Beyond being indexed and able to show a snippet, it says, “There are no additional technical requirements.”

Keep schema as housekeeping. Mark up what’s visible on the page, keep it accurate, and expect it to help machines read your facts, not to change who gets recommended. This page uses FAQ schema for that reason only: it describes the questions you can read at the bottom.

Does blocking AI training also block AI search visibility?

No, they’re separate switches. OpenAI uses GPTBot for training and OAI-SearchBot for search, and each can be allowed or blocked on its own.

OpenAI’s crawler page says “Each setting is independent of the others.” Block GPTBot in your robots.txt file and your pages stay out of future training. Block OAI-SearchBot and your site “will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers”, which is rarely what a business wants. Anthropic and Google split the two jobs in a similar way.

The crawlers OpenAI, Anthropic and Google use for AI training and for search
CompanyUsed for trainingUsed for search
OpenAIGPTBotOAI-SearchBot
AnthropicClaudeBotClaude-SearchBot
GoogleGoogle-ExtendedGooglebot

Two of those need a note. Anthropic also runs Claude-User, which fetches a page when someone asks Claude a question that needs it. And Google-Extended isn’t a separate crawler. It’s a label in robots.txt that tells Google whether pages Googlebot has crawled can be used to train its AI models, and blocking it doesn’t take you out of AI Overviews or AI Mode.

To keep your pages out of Google’s AI answers specifically, Google added a setting in Search Console. It was tested in the UK first and reached all sites by 31 August 2026. Whatever you decide about training, check that your robots.txt file lets OAI-SearchBot, Claude-SearchBot and Googlebot in.

Does publishing more content automatically improve AI visibility?

No. Volume alone doesn’t do it, and Google treats pages mass-produced to game rankings or AI answers as spam. What gets cited is original, specific content that answers a real question.

Google’s guide to generative AI features asks for “non-commodity” content built on first-hand experience. In plain terms, that’s a page offering something a reader can’t get from ten others saying the same thing. The guide warns against pages mass-produced to manipulate rankings or AI answers, however they were written.

So AEO doesn’t mean filling your website with AI-generated articles. One page with your own prices, process and examples is worth more than twenty generic posts, whoever or whatever wrote them. What works instead is finding the questions customers ask that your site doesn’t answer yet, and answering them with what only you know.

Does AEO require us to rewrite our entire website?

No. Most of what AI cites about a business isn’t on its website. In Tilio’s study of 44,587 AI answers, 96.5% of citations went to sites the brand didn’t own.

The other half of the finding is why a few pages still matter. When an answer named the brand, it cited the brand’s own site 80% of the time. The pages that say what you sell, who it’s for and what it costs carry most of the weight on your own site.

So start with those few pages, then look outward at the sources AI draws on: the reviews, directories and publications it reads about your category. Our guide to which pages to fix first sets out the order, and our study of how often AI cites brand websites has the full figures, from four UK brands over 30 days.

Is being recommended by AI the same as having a high search ranking?

No, though the two overlap. Ahrefs found 38% of pages cited in Google’s AI Overviews also ranked in the top 10 for the same search, down from about 76% in July 2025.

Ahrefs’ study, published on 2 March 2026, covered 863,000 searches, and the exact figure was 37.9%. Ranking still helps an engine find your page. It no longer decides whether you’re cited, let alone named.

Optimising for AI doesn’t come at the cost of normal search. Google says its usual Search guidance applies to its AI features too, so clear, original, well-structured pages help with both.

Can an agency control how AI describes our brand in every answer?

No, but it can change what the AI has to work from. Assistants build their descriptions from your site and from what others publish about you, so the fix is to correct those sources.

Even an authoritative source can be cited and still misdescribed. The UK Government’s guidance for its own communicators reports an Office for National Statistics assessment of AI Overviews: the ONS was cited at a rate of 97%, with an accuracy rate of 21%. Being the source didn’t make the answer right.

So the work happens upstream. Find the pages an assistant relies on when it describes you, correct what’s wrong or out of date, and check whether the answer changes. Our guide to when AI says the wrong thing about your brand covers each step.

Can AI visibility improve even when website traffic stays flat?

Yes. Many people who see a business in an AI answer never click through, and those who do often arrive later by another route. Traffic reports miss both.

Similarweb found that of the visits following a ChatGPT recommendation, only 8.8% arrived as an AI referral, according to PPC Land’s report of the study. Most came later through search or direct, where analytics can’t tie them to ChatGPT.

So judge AI visibility on more than traffic: how often you’re named, brand searches over time and what customers say when you ask how they found you. Our guide on how to check if customers really found you through ChatGPT puts those together.

Why might an AEO campaign not produce more leads?

Because being named isn’t the same as being chosen. Leads stall when you’re visible for questions customers don’t ask, when the pages AI cites lead nowhere, or when nobody’s counting enquiries from AI.

  • The questions are wrong. You’re named for questions nobody with a budget asks. Track the questions customers ask before they buy, not the ones that are easy to win.
  • The cited pages lead nowhere. AI sends people to an article with no next step. Give every page AI cites a clear route to an enquiry.
  • The description puts people off. You’re named with an old price, the wrong area or a service you’ve stopped offering. Correct the sources the description comes from.
  • Nobody’s counting. Enquiries arrive and nobody asks where they came from. Add “How did you first hear about us?” to every form and first call.
  • It’s too early. Being named more often comes before enquiries, and a long sales cycle takes longer still. Agree what you’ll judge, and when, before the work starts.

If counting is the gap, our AI search attribution setup joins your analytics, Search Console, Business Hub and the question on your forms into one view.

What claims about AI search optimisation should you question?

Question any guarantee, any promise of instant results, any single fix and any score with no method behind it. Google itself advises caution with tools that promise ranking success.

Here are five claims you might hear, and the question that tests each one.

Five claims about AI search optimisation and the question to ask about each
The claimThe question to ask
“We guarantee you’ll be recommended”Who controls the answer, and what happens if it doesn’t appear?
“You’ll see results within days”Which result, measured how, and over how many weeks?
“This one fix gets you into AI answers”What evidence shows it changed who gets recommended?
“Your visibility score is up 10 points”How many questions and answers sit behind it, and how far does it move by chance?
“We can make AI say what you want”Which sources will you change, and how will we see the answer change?

The difference between an evidence-based AEO service and a sales pitch is usually in what you can check. Evidence comes with the questions tracked, the dated answers behind each figure, and a record of what changed and when. Testing with a handful of questions swings too much to trust, as our guide on how to sanity check an AI visibility score shows, and our guide on how to choose an AEO agency has more questions to ask.

Tilio, a UK AEO agency, starts with a baseline of the questions your customers ask, measured before anything changes. We don’t guarantee recommendations. We report how often you’re named, cited and described accurately, show you the answers behind the figures, and choose the next piece of work from what the evidence shows.

Frequently asked questions

Is AEO a lasting marketing discipline or a temporary trend?

The label may change, but the channel is here. OpenAI says 1.2 billion people use ChatGPT each week, and Google Analytics now reports AI assistants as a channel of their own. Making a business easy for those assistants to find and describe accurately will matter for as long as people ask them.

Does a strong brand reputation make AEO unnecessary?

It helps, and it isn’t enough. In Tilio’s study of 44,587 AI answers, four UK brands went unnamed in 86% of the answers to questions in their own categories. A reputation has to be written down where AI reads it, on your own site and on the sites it trusts.

Can AEO work without a blog or a large publishing budget?

Yes. Service pages, FAQs, About pages and coverage on other sites are what AI cites about a business. A few strong, specific pages do more than many thin ones.

Can a UK agency really influence results from global AI platforms?

Not the platform itself, but the sources it reads. AI answers are built from web pages, reviews and directories, and those can be improved from anywhere. That’s where any agency’s influence lies, wherever it’s based.

Is UK AEO different enough to require a local specialist?

UK answers draw on UK sources, prices, regulators and spelling, so they need testing in the UK. What matters most is that the measuring is done in your own market, with questions written the way UK customers ask them.

Should we trust an AEO provider that promises immediate results?

Be wary. A new page can be cited within days, but a lasting rise in how often you’re named is judged over months, not a week. Ask which result is promised, how it will be measured and over what period.

What an AEO pilot should test in its first three months

Is it possible to optimise for AI without damaging our normal search performance?

Yes. Google says its usual Search guidance applies to its AI features too, so clear, original, well-structured pages help with both. Good AEO work doesn’t ask you to trade one for the other.

Written by Jack F, co-founder of Tilio, a UK AEO agency that tracks how businesses appear in AI answers and works to improve it. More about Jack F